Budget Airlines Are Collapsing, and So Is the Cheap Flight

Coffee's on.

The quiet death of the cheap flight, and why your wallet should care even if you never flew Spirit.

Mug up.

America's budget airlines are collapsing, and the cheap flight is dying with them.

Spirit shut down in May after three decades in the air. Frontier and JetBlue are both deep in the red. Fewer no-frills carriers means a higher floor under every fare you book, even the pricey legacy seats.

Everyone blames jet fuel.

But the real killer had Spirit cornered years before a single barrel spiked.

The budget model was fragile by design.

Sell a rock-bottom base fare, then bill for the bag, the seat, the snack and the changed mind. It prints cash when oil is cheap and cabins are packed. Strip out every frill, though, and you strip out every cushion.

When costs jump, nothing is left to cut.

Then the giants came for the cheap seats.

American, Delta, and United bolted on basic economy, copying the upstarts' own trick: a cheap headline fare with fees tacked onto the rest. The difference was the cushion. The majors had premium cabins, loyalty schemes, and credit card deals worth billions of dollars a year. Spirit had none.

Spirit last booked a profit in 2019, and never found another.

Fuel finished the job.

US carriers' fuel bill hit $5.06bn in March, up 56% in one month and 30% on a year earlier, per the Transport Department. Fuel is now the industry's top cost, ahead of labour, at roughly 31% of expenses. Spirit's chief said crude above $100 a barrel in April sank the airline's escape from bankruptcy:

"We just kind of ran out of runway."

But people didn't stop flying.

They stopped flying cheap. United booked record 2025 revenue of $59bn, with premium takings up 11%. The bargain seat lost to the fancy one. Ryanair and easyJet still mint money in Europe on short hops and lean costs.

America's discounters had the thin fares and none of the cushions.

Now one fewer airline is left to undercut the rest, and fares are already up more than 20% on last year.

The cheap seat didn't just die (it got bought out).

Pro: Cheap flying isn't doomed. Spirit was barely 2% of US flyers, ran serial bankruptcies and dire service, and no-frills still thrives in Europe.

Con: In a high-fuel world, a wafer-thin fare with no premium cabin or card cushion can't absorb a shock; the maths only works when oil is cheap.

Our read: Flyers never stopped wanting cheap; Spirit just lacked the cushion to keep selling at that price. Now the giants own the bargain seat, with no upstart left to keep them honest.

[Report] United Airlines — "Fourth-Quarter and Full-Year 2025 Results"

Record $59.1bn in revenue and $4.3bn in pre-tax profit, with premium-cabin revenue up 11% for the year.

Why it matters: same fuel prices, opposite results. United sold premium and got rich while Spirit sold cheap and died. The model was the difference, not the market.

Airlines now earn roughly $4.50 per passenger. — IATA, 2026 forecast

[Analysis] CNBC — "World Cup travel boost hasn't materialised — yet" — Even a global mega-event isn't the uniform travel boom airlines banked on; price-shy fans are baulking at the fares.

[Analysis] The Travel — "A World Cup demand shock, no new seats" — Jet fuel at $152 a barrel is now airlines' highest cost, overtaking labour. The maths behind every hike.

[Report] CNBC — "Walmart's digital price tags reach every US store" — The hide-the-real-price playbook the airlines wrote is spreading to your grocery shelf.

When you book a flight, what do you really optimise for?

You can read all our back issue newsletters for free here.

For the love of coffee, see you tomorrow!

Enjoy your Monday, keep it caffeinated.

Your Monday brew, poured before we run out of runway.

Thanks for reading!

Are you subscribing?

Join your crew of caffeinated sceptics today.

Be sure to get your daily Curse and Coffee fix by hitting the button below.

Open Monday to Friday.