America's College Enrollment Cliff Claims Its First Big Name

Happy Thursday.

Everyone saw this coming. An interstate education commission flagged it in 2012. A dozen economists modelled it.

And still, somehow, nobody did a thing.

Coffee at the ready…

The college enrolment cliff has a body count now, and every administrator in America saw it coming.

Hampshire College, the Massachusetts liberal arts school where Ken Burns studied, announced permanent closure on Tuesday. Huron Consulting Group says 442 private colleges will follow in the next decade. The cliff was mapped in 2012.

The response was a shrug and a tuition hike.

Welcome to American higher education.

Before we slurp into today’s brew…

Here are some wordies from today’s sponsor.

Intrepid's co-founder and CEO don't do corporate gloss. Their opening letter in the Integrated Annual Report gets into what 2025 actually required: the hard calls, the strategy reset, and how a nearly 30% growth year still came with real challenges.

Read their story

This didn't sneak up on anyone.

The U.S. birth rate peaked in 2007, then plunged during the Great Recession. A 2012 report from WICHE, the Western Interstate Commission for Higher Education, flagged the coming enrolment drop. Nathan Grawe published a book on it. Conference panels discussed it. Most small colleges responded by raising tuition and hoping for the best. Grawe's models project a 15% drop in traditional-age demand between 2025 and 2029.

This was predictable. It was predicted. It happened.

Hampshire's numbers tell you how it ends — even when you try.

The school raised $55 million, recruited students from collapsing rivals, and launched a five-year rescue plan. It still needed 300 new students last autumn. It got 168. A $26.5 million endowment sounds healthy — until you learn $23.5 million was restricted, untouchable for daily operations. A $21 million bond debt comes due in September with no refinancing in sight. The accreditor didn't save the school. It buried it faster.

The students get a transfer pathway and a refund cheque.

The damage won't stay on campus.

Huron's forecast covers roughly a quarter of all 1,700 private, non-profit four-year colleges in the country. More than 120 sit at the very highest risk. The closures could displace around 600,000 students and shake $18 billion in endowment funds. Everyone saw the cliff.

Nobody built a plan for the landing.

Small college towns feel it worst — and they had the least say in any of it.

In Macomb, Illinois, Western Illinois University lost half its students since 2010. The town's population fell 20%. Close the school, and you close the landlord, the employer, and the pipeline of young people who stick around and build something.

Now multiply it by 442.

Pro: Market correction is overdue — fewer weak schools means stronger outcomes for students who do enrol, and forces the sector to justify its price tag.

Con: Rural and working-class communities lose their only nearby college, their biggest employer, and the pipeline of graduates who stay and build local economies.

Our read: The correction is real. But calling it a "market correction" lets a lot of decision-makers off the hook for 18 years of inaction.

[Analysis] The Hechinger Report / Huron Consulting Group — "More than a quarter of private colleges are at risk of closing"

Huron analysed enrolment trends, tuition revenue, assets, debt, and cash reserves across 1,700 private non-profits. Result: 442 face closure or merger. More than 120 are in the highest-risk tier.

Why it matters: This isn't a vibes-based warning. It's the most granular forecast yet on which schools go dark — and it says the shakeout is just starting.

Only 22% of Americans think college is worth it if loans are involved. — Pew Research Centre

Fortune — Google's Sergey Brin says he's hiring "tons" without degrees — The demand side of the degree equation is cracking too.

Education Next — Colleges Are Closing. Who Might Be Next? — Machine learning models map the closures to come and the towns they'll gut.

NPR — More than a quarter of private colleges are at risk — Sterling College in Vermont offers a glimpse at the human side of the shakeout.

You can read all our back issue newsletters for free here.

For the love of coffee, see you tomorrow!

Enjoy your Thursday, keep it caffeinated.

Thanks for reading!

Are you subscribing?

Join your crew of caffeinated sceptics today.

Be sure to get your daily Curse and Coffee fix by hitting the button below.

Open Monday to Friday.

Read yesterday’s newsletter about the Rockstar Games data breach here.

Learn how to read any government/company PDF without crying!

Take advantage of what others miss. We teach you how to extract the gems from the dirt.

Share the Curse and Coffee newsletter with just 1 real person to download your Receipts Toolkit instantly—a field guide for caffeinated sceptics who want to pull signal from filings, datasets, and reports.

No law degree needed—a no-nap promise.

Unlock and never struggle to identify opportunities in long, drawn-out documents again.

“Receipts over vibes. Always.”

Thank you for sharing…

And be sure to use your toolkit to extract max alpha from any document you read.

Stay Caffinated!