Rob Manfred Killed ESPN's Baseball Deal. Now Fans Need Six Subscriptions.

Happy Monday.

Fifty million people watched the World Series last year. Best ratings in 34 years. Attendance rising. And the suits are about to torch the whole thing over a spreadsheet argument.

Grab the coffee…

Baseball finally got good again, and then the front office got greedy.

The league's collective bargaining agreement expires on December 1. The players' union says a lockout is "all but guaranteed." We think the real fight isn't salary caps — it's your TV screen. Commissioner Rob Manfred called ESPN a "shrinking platform" 14 months ago and tore up a $550 million-a-year deal.

For a league where a third of teams couldn't find a local TV partner until last Wednesday, the man has nerve.

Negotiations start after Opening Day. The clock runs out on December 1.

Before we slurp into today’s brew…

Here are some wordies from today’s sponsor.

ChatGPT is insanely powerful.

But most people waste 90% of its potential by using it like Google.

These 1,000+ proven ChatGPT prompts fix that and help you work 10X faster.

Sign up for Superhuman AI and get:

Claim your free prompts

MLB pulled in $13.1 billion in revenue last year. Franchise values jumped 13%. The average club is worth $2.95 billion.

The Yankees?

$9.4 billion.

The Marlins?

$1.4 billion.

Same sport. Same rules. Different planet.

Owners want a salary cap. They say it's about parity. The receipts say otherwise.

Cleveland earned $337 million last year and spent $102 million on players—operating income: a cool $51 million. The Guardians aren't struggling.

They're hoarding.

Fair point in the other direction:

The Dodgers just won back-to-back World Series on record payrolls.

If you're a Reds fan, the game feels rigged. A spending floor — which the union actually supports — would force cheap owners to invest. But the cap is a different animal. It wouldn't lift the bottom. It would lower the ceiling. Union interim boss Bruce Meyer took over in February after Tony Clark resigned amid an internal investigation.

He didn't mince words: a cap is "bad for players on multiple levels."

Then there's the screen.

Manfred blew up the ESPN deal chasing a bigger pot. So baseball in 2026 is split across NBC, ESPN, Fox, TBS, Apple TV+ and Netflix. Want full national coverage? Six subscriptions. Over $100 a month. Local games cost extra. Fifteen years ago, one cable package got you everything. Your dad watched every inning on one channel.

Now the sport treats loyal fans like ATMs with legs.

Manfred's big swing:

Seize local rights from all 30 teams by 2028. Bundle the lot.

Auction it to one streamer for what could dwarf the $550 million ESPN paid. If the lockout bleeds into 2027 and kills real games for the first time since 1995, those media negotiations could collapse the moment he needs them most — or buyers could smell a bargain.

Either way, he's gambling the whole sport on a deal he hasn't closed yet.

Pro: A floor would force the Clevelands and Miamis to spend. Pair it with a cap, and the payroll gap shrinks from a canyon to a crack.

Con: Every cap in every sport has capped player earnings first. And MLB's thriftiest owners have already shown they'll bank revenue before spending it.

Our read: The cap talk is theatre. The real fight is media rights. Fans are footing the bill either way.

[Analysis] Sportico — "MLB Team Values 2026"

Average team revenue: $426 million. Average EBITDA margin: under 2% — dead last among the Big Four leagues.

Why it matters: Franchise values up 13% while profits barely register. Owners pleading poverty with $3 billion price tags. The union will print this on a poster.

Six subscriptions to watch one sport.

[Awful Announcing]

CNBC — Sony shoves PS5 prices up by $150. The Pro now costs $900. Memory chip shortages are real, but nine hundred dollars for a games console is a number you have to sit with.

Federal News Network — Trump orders TSA staff paid during the DHS shutdown after agents missed three paychecks. Callout rates hit 12% nationally. Spring break travellers: godspeed.

The Ringer — The best deep dive on every thread in the MLB labour fight. If today's issue hooked you, this one reels you in.

You can read all our back issue newsletters for free here.

For the love of coffee, see you tomorrow!

Enjoy your Monday, keep it caffeinated.

Thanks for reading!

Are you subscribing?

Join your crew of caffeinated sceptics today.

Be sure to get your daily Curse and Coffee fix by hitting the button below.

Open Monday to Friday.

Read yesterday’s newsletter about the Meta verdict here.

Learn how to read any government/company PDF without crying!

Take advantage of what others miss. We teach you how to extract the gems from the dirt.

Share the Curse and Coffee newsletter with just 1 real person to download your Receipts Toolkit instantly—a field guide for caffeinated sceptics who want to pull signal from filings, datasets, and reports.

No law degree needed—a no-nap promise.

Unlock and never struggle to identify opportunities in long, drawn-out documents again.

“Receipts over vibes. Always.”

Thank you for sharing…

And be sure to use your toolkit to extract max alpha from any document you read.

Stay Caffinated!