Nike Hit Its Diversity Targets. The Feds Hit Back.

Hooray for Thursday!

Hello, Curse and Coffee friends,

Today, we explore Nike Vs. The Feds.

Hit reply and let us know what you think (we read all of your kind words).

Coffee at the ready…

The take: Nike didn't just meet its diversity goals. It crushed them. That's now Exhibit A.

What happened: The EEOC filed a federal subpoena enforcement action on Wednesday to force Nike to hand over records dating back to 2018.

Why it matters: For five years, companies posted diversity targets to show they weren't racist. Now the feds are using those same documents to argue they were.

What to watch: Nike calls the subpoena "an impermissible fishing expedition." If the court agrees, companies exhale. If not, every HR department starts shredding by Monday.

Nike's target was 35%. It hit 41%. In most companies, that's a bonus. In this one, it's a subpoena.

Nike published diversity targets in 2021.

It tied executive pay to hitting them. It reported progress publicly. Every word is now discoverable.

The EEOC's theory: if you set a number, you created a quota.

If you rewarded executives for reaching it, you incentivised discrimination. The agency doesn't need to prove Nike rejected a white applicant.

It just needs to show the target existed and decisions followed.

For five years, companies were told transparency was the shield. Report your numbers. Show your work. Prove you're not discriminating.

Nike did exactly that.

Now the same paper trail that protected them from one lawsuit feeds another.

DEI programmes weren't killed by their failures.

They're being killed by their receipts. The companies that documented the least may survive the longest.

Silence is the new strategy.

Pro: Title VII doesn't have a favourite race. If targets became quotas, the law applies. Full stop.

Con: Programmes built to fix exclusion are now called "the real discrimination." Neat trick. Turn the cure into the disease.

Our read: Legally, this hinges on whether Nike crossed from opening doors to closing them. But the politics aren't subtle. The feds want boardrooms to feel the chill.

[Primary Source] Nike's 2025 Targets PDF. The sentence doing all the work: "Executive compensation tied to diversity goals." Read it before the lawyers do.

Nike Purpose Report

Target: 35%. Result: 41%. Reward: subpoena.

Nike FY23 Impact Report

1. Missouri sued Starbucks on similar DEI claims last February. Same federal court district. Different prosecutor. That was the state AG. This is the feds. The playbook is spreading. CNN

2. The EEOC chair posted a video in December asking white men to file discrimination complaints. Quiet part loud. Axios

3. Nike cut 775 jobs last week. The feds now want to know how they picked who got cut. Timing is everything. Fox Business

You can read all our back issue newsletters for free here.

For the love of coffee, see you tomorrow!

Enjoy your Thursday, keep it caffeinated.

Thanks for reading!

Are you subscribing?

Join your crew of caffeinated sceptics today.

Be sure to get your daily Curse and Coffee fix by hitting the button below.

Open Monday to Friday.