Happy Friday.
If you opened your portfolio this morning and the software column was red, sip your coffee first.
Then read this.
A dozen-plus analysts saw yesterday coming.
Worth knowing why…
The Big Sip
The SaaS AI disruption finally hit.
ServiceNow fell 18% yesterday — its worst day on record. IBM dropped 8%. Salesforce, Workday, and Adobe all bled. The thing is: a UBS analyst named Karl Keirstead saw it coming.
He told his clients exactly why in a research note last December.
Wall Street has spent the past 3 weeks quietly catching up.
Yesterday…
Here’s Your Brew
Start with the scissors.
UBS cut ServiceNow from Buy to Neutral on April 10 and slashed its target from $170 to $100. Stifel, RBC, Mizuho, TD Cowen, JPMorgan, Morgan Stanley, Citigroup, Evercore, Deutsche Bank, BMO, Needham, BTIG, KeyBanc and Raymond James followed. More than a dozen downgrades. 3 weeks.
When the analyst consensus turns that fast, the narrative has already moved — the price is just catching up.
The UBS note is where this started.
Since December, analyst Karl Keirstead has been hearing the same sentence from Fortune 500 buyers: core software budgets are "under greater pressure." Read it twice. Not cancelled. Pressured. The money is going to GPU clusters and Anthropic API credits instead. ServiceNow's product is fine.
The customer's wallet just changed shape.
See the procurement manager at a mid-sized insurer.
Last year, she renewed Workday, Salesforce and ServiceNow without blinking. This year, her CFO wants the AI budget tripled, and someone has to find the money. She opens the SaaS spend sheet. Every line is a target. That conversation is happening in a thousand rooms right now.
Wall Street finally priced it.
The carnage extended beyond two names.
Salesforce fell 9%. Workday fell 9% and is down 45% year-to-date. Adobe, Oracle, Intuit and HubSpot all bled between 6% and 9%. That's not a reaction to one earnings call.
It's the entire sector getting its story rewritten in a single session.
ServiceNow has a hedge.
Its Now Assist product lets customers pay per AI task instead of per seat. Customers spending a million a year on it are up 130%. That's the company eating its own per-seat business before Salesforce manages to.
The problem: one division cannibalising another isn't two divisions growing, no matter how the press release frames it.
Two Sides, One Mug
Pro: ServiceNow beat earnings, raised Now Assist target $500M, and grew $5M+ customers 22%. Goldman and BofA reiterated Buy on IBM. Not everyone sold.
Con: More than a dozen analysts cut targets before the crash. KeyBanc now sees $85. The narrative is outrunning the fundamentals.
Our read: Per-seat pricing is on the clock. Management teams reading Iran headlines instead of pricing sheets will keep getting sold.
Receipt of the Day
[Analysis] UBS Research Note, Karl Keirstead — "AI is a bigger threat than first believed"
Keirstead wrote that since December, Fortune 500 firms have been telling UBS core software budgets are under pressure. AI infrastructure spending is squeezing them.
Why it matters: The crash wasn't a Wednesday surprise. It was the market finally agreeing with a four-month-old research note.
Spit Take
ServiceNow raised its AI target by $500M. Stock fell 18%.
Extra Curricular Coffee Break Links
24/7 Wall St — UBS cuts ServiceNow, calls yesterday's selloff "just the beginning" — the two-week-old warning that just came true.
CNBC — Software stocks plunge as AI fears escalate — a clean tally of which SaaS names got hit and by how much.
Benzinga — AI Anxiety Returns — the case that proprietary AI tools are breaking the SaaS margin stack.
Mugshot Poll 📊
Your software stocks just crashed. What are you doing on Monday?
Buying the dip — fundamentals still work
Trimming — the thesis is broken
Holding — I'll know more in 90 days
Pretending I didn't look
You can read all our back issue newsletters for free here.
For the love of coffee, see you Monday!
Enjoy your Friday, keep it caffeinated.
That's Friday.
If your portfolio looks worse than your Monday, that's real, and so is the hangover. Take the weekend.
Read the UBS note.
Come back Monday with a sharper question than "should I sell?"
Read yesterday’s newsletter about Tesla’s bomb here.
Thanks for reading!
Are you subscribing?
Join your crew of caffeinated sceptics today.
Be sure to get your daily Curse and Coffee fix by hitting the button below.
Open Monday to Friday.